Authenticated user menu

Search
Blog
14 December 2011
Number of comments
3
Total views

Have it done to you or get involved

I was intrigued when I first heard about the Faculty of Medical Leadership and Management (FMLM). As a doctor, who took the unusual step of moving into full time NHS management in 2004, I have felt somewhat unsupported by the medical establishment in my chosen path. The creation of the FMLM, suggests to me, that this may be changing.

I have recently returned from a study visit to integrated care organisations on the West Coast of America. What struck me was how integral and valued medical leadership was in those organisations. Right from the very top of a large health group down to a clinic in a shopping mall the medical profession informed, influenced and led the organisation. Is the time right for the medical profession in the UK to embrace leadership and management in a way never seen before?

My own transition, from full time working with patients to full time working on the system to support individual care and health, happened over many years. Prior to August 2004, I had worked as a GP for 14 years during which time my development and acquisition of management skills was supported by the NHS. It was, however, incredibly ad-hoc and mostly adapted from training provided for consultants who were interested in getting involved in hospital management. I would have welcomed something like the FMLM at the time.

There were some formative moments in those years. The first was in a learning set when a Vice Chancellor from a well known university came to talk about the reforms in progress at the time. It was 1998 and the new government had announced the proposals for Primary Care Groups. The VC leant forwards and said “Well you lot have a choice. You can either have it done to you or get involved. What’s it to be?” That challenge is one which is still pertinent – sometimes I feel the medical profession views management of the health system with a degree of disdain; yet is bemused by what is done to the profession without its involvement.

A second event in my career was the opportunity to attend the clinical strategist course at INSEAD. It offered me a whole new insight into ideas, experience, evidence and concepts that could be used to improve health and health care. Given the challenges which health systems face worldwide, I feel similar courses should be made more available to doctors – perhaps something the FMLM could/should promote?

Finally, I would reflect on a comment a long-time mentor made, very early on in my transition. Nearly twenty years ago he told me that taking on a leadership role could be very lonely at times and one of the most important resources you need to draw upon is yourself. Understanding yourself is critical, in my opinion, to enter the world of leadership and management. However, it is also an immense support to know others in a similar position who you can call on for support, advice and help. That, to me, will be a great role for the FMLM and I urge the medical profession to support its development and membership.

 or  Register to add a comment

About the author

Martin McShane's picture

Martin McShane

Martin McShane qualified in 1981 and has experience in the acute sector, primary care and NHS management.

He is interested in realising the potential of primary care, supporting integrated care and clinical leadership.

He also does triathlons - slowly.

Also by Martin McShane

Jobs

Comments

12 years 3 months ago

Doctors in senior general management leadership roles

Martin, you have described very well the challenges of moving from the more usual clinical director/medical director type of role, for doctors keen to play a part in management, to the roles traditionally occupied by those from a general management background such as COO/CEO. We know that only around 4% of CEO's in NHS England in 2010 (and none in NHS Wales) havd a medical background. The barriers to increasing this further are significant and include the need for formal development programmes aimed at taking this bold step as well as the need for mentorship and support.

Whilst it is right that the FMLM is concentrating initially on the CD/MD cohort, like you I hope that a specific focus can be developed for those of us in other executive director roles as doctors. I have just completed the Diploma in Organisational Leadership at Oxford (Said Business School) http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk/execed/leadership/DOL/Pages/default.aspx and found it very helpful for my leadership development and the academic rigour it required familiar and reassuring although a little stressful at times!

12 years 4 months ago

MBAs

I know several Medics who have done an MBA and benefited immensely from it.

I know I couldn't just do management when I started and am still learning from many people who I work with. I hope I bring something that adds to their skills and experience but it has been really important for me to immerse myself to feel that I can synergise with them.

I have been a surgeon and a GP - both terrifically demanding jobs. Management has stretched me as much, if not more than my clinical roles. 

Training and development is always of value.

12 years 4 months ago

Views on MBA

Thanks Martin. I am interested in hearing views on the role and value of strudying an MBA to support clinical leaders transfering into a management career. I began my MBA with the OU 2 yeras ago and aim to finish it next year and have self funded it. My student colleagues from industry are (almost al) sponsored yet there are very few NHS clinical leaders at all and those that are present are self funded (almost all). Are we missing an oportuity to give clinical leaders a view into the world of management outside of the NHS? Iit has been this that I have valued the most from my studues. I also worrry that some clinicans thing they can 'just do' management and whilst an MBA is no substitute for experience it does offer theory and increasingly eviedence based views on how to succed as a manager. I feel it has made a significant difference to my outlook on both management and how to support my organisation in delivering its strategic aims and objectives which is arguably what our role as clinical managers is based around.

Array ( [0] => sitewide [1] => advert_external_leaderboard [2] => not_front_desktop [3] => advert_external_wideskyscraper [4] => comments [5] => comments_login_prompt [6] => jobs_content_pages [7] => node-social-accelerators [8] => node_blog [9] => related_content [10] => advert_internal_desktop )